Skip to content


Barber applying styling product to a man's hair, possibly using hair putty vs pomade, as part of the Beard Beasts men's grooming experience.

Hair Putty vs Pomade

When it comes to styling your hair, the array of products available can be overwhelming. Among the most popular choices are hair putty vs pomade, each offering unique benefits for different hair types and styles. But how do you decide which one is right for you?

This article delves into the key differences between hair putty and pomade, exploring their textures, holds, finishes, and suitability for various hair types. Whether you're aiming for a casual, textured look or a sleek, polished appearance, understanding the nuances of hair putty vs pomade can help you achieve your desired hairstyle with confidence.

We'll guide you through the pros and cons, application tips, and how to choose the best product for your styling needs, ensuring that you make an informed decision to elevate your hair game.

Get ready to discover the perfect styling companion for your locks, keeping your hair looking its best while catering to your personal preferences and lifestyle.

Man showcasing a sleek pompadour hairstyle, a potential result of choosing between hair putty vs pomade, with a sharp beard, symbolizing Beard Beasts men's grooming excellence.

What is Hair Putty?

Hair putty, often a game-changer in the styling world, offers a versatile approach to shaping and molding your hair to perfection. Unlike its counterpart in the hair putty vs pomade debate, hair putty provides a matte finish, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a natural look without the glossy shine.

Definition and Key Characteristics

Hair putty is a thick, moldable styling product designed to hold your hair in place while allowing flexibility and movement. Its texture is somewhat similar to clay, offering a stronghold without stiffness, which means you can restyle your hair throughout the day. The matte finish it provides is perfect for creating textured, effortless styles that look like you haven't tried too hard.

Primary Ingredients and Their Effects on Hair

The magic of hair putty lies in its ingredients. Commonly made with natural waxes, clays, and oils, these components work together to nourish your hair while providing hold. Clays, such as bentonite or kaolin, absorb excess oil, making hair putty a great option for those with oily hair types. Waxes, including beeswax and carnauba, offer the malleable hold that lets you sculpt your hair, while oils like coconut or argan moisturize and protect the hair shaft from damage.

The combination of these ingredients ensures that hair putty not only styles your hair but also improves its health and texture over time. It's a styling product that works with your hair, not against it, maintaining its natural balance and vitality.

When choosing between hair putty vs pomade, consider the finish and hold you're aiming for. If a natural, textured style with a matte finish is your goal, hair putty is your go-to styling ally. It's about embracing your hair's natural flow while giving it just the right amount of direction and control.

What is Pomade?

Pomade stands out as a classic styling product, bridging the gap between modern and vintage hairstyles. Within the context of hair putty vs pomade, pomade leans towards providing a sleek, shiny finish, making it a favorite for those aiming for polished, well-defined styles.

Definition and Key Characteristics

Pomade is a smooth, often shiny styling product designed to give hair a strong hold and a slick appearance. Its consistency can range from a soft cream to a hard wax, but its defining feature is its ability to impart a glossy shine, ideal for slicked-back looks, pompadours, and classic side parts. Unlike hair putty, pomade excels in creating more structured hairstyles that require a lasting hold and a noticeable sheen.

Primary Ingredients and Their Effects on Hair

Pomades may be water-based or oil-based, each with its unique benefits. Water-based pomades offer a strong hold with the convenience of easy washing, making them a great choice for daily use without worrying about build-up. Oil-based variants, on the other hand, provide a heavier hold and higher shine but can be more challenging to wash out.

Key ingredients in pomades include water or petroleum (for the base), as well as various oils like castor or coconut for nourishment and shine. Some formulations also contain waxes to enhance hold. These ingredients work together to smooth the hair, reduce frizz, and maintain a styled look throughout the day. Additionally, the oils in pomade can help condition the hair, though it's essential to find the right balance to avoid greasiness.

In the debate of hair putty vs pomade, your choice depends on the style you're after and your hair's needs. If a glossy finish and a sculpted hairstyle are what you desire, pomade could be your perfect match. It's not just about holding your hair in place; it's about elevating your style with a signature shine and precision.

Hair Putty vs Pomade: The Comparison

When navigating the world of hair styling products, understanding the nuances between hair putty and pomade can make all the difference in achieving your desired look. Let's dive into their texture and consistency, hold and shine, and application and styling tips.

Texture and Consistency

Hair Putty: Known for its matte finish, hair putty has a thick, pliable texture that's easy to work with. It feels slightly tacky to the touch, which helps it grip the hair for easy styling. This consistency is perfect for sculpting and reshaping, offering a flexibility that's ideal for casual, textured looks.

Pomade: Pomade typically has a smoother, more gel-like consistency, especially the water-based varieties. Oil-based pomades are denser and can feel a bit greasier. Both types glide through the hair easily, lending themselves to sleek, shiny styles that stay put.

Hold and Shine

Hair Putty: Offers a medium to strong hold with a matte finish, making it excellent for adding texture without the shine. It's fantastic for voluminous styles or a more natural, effortless look that lasts all day without looking stiff or greasy.

Pomade: Delivers a variable hold, from medium to strong, depending on the formula. The signature of pomade is its shine, ranging from a subtle glow to a high gloss, perfect for polished styles that need a sleek edge.

Application and Styling Tips

Best Practices for Applying Hair Putty:

  • Start with a small amount, warming it up between your palms.
  • Apply evenly through dry or slightly damp hair, starting from the back and working your way to the front.
  • Style with your fingers or a comb for texture or definition.

Best Practices for Applying Pomade:

  • Use a dime-sized amount for medium hold; adjust for stronger hold or thicker hair.
  • Pomade is best applied to damp hair for easier distribution.
  • Use a comb for sleek styles or your fingers for a more relaxed look.

Styling Tips:

  • Hair Putty: Ideal for messy, bedhead styles, or adding volume to thin hair. It's great for a tousled look that can be reworked throughout the day.
  • Pomade: Perfect for classic, slicked-back looks like pompadours or side parts. It can also tame curly or unruly hair, giving it a neat, glossy finish.

In the hair putty vs pomade debate, the right choice depends on the style you're aiming for and your hair type. Hair putty offers flexibility and a natural look, while pomade provides sleekness and shine. Experimenting with both products can help you discover the perfect fit for your styling needs, ensuring your hair always looks its best.

Hair Putty vs Pomade: Pros and Cons

When considering hair putty vs pomade, it's essential to weigh their advantages and disadvantages. Each product offers unique benefits and potential drawbacks, depending on your hair type, style preferences, and lifestyle. Let’s break down the pros and cons to help you choose the right product for your hair.

Advantages of Using Hair Putty

  • Versatility: Hair putty is incredibly versatile, suitable for a wide range of hairstyles from casual to textured looks. It’s great for both short and medium-length hair.
  • Matte Finish: For those who prefer a natural, no-shine look, hair putty provides a matte finish that enhances texture without appearing greasy.
  • Reworkable: Many hair putties allow you to rework your style throughout the day, offering flexibility that's perfect for on-the-go adjustments.
  • Strong Hold: Despite its flexibility, hair putty typically offers a strong hold, keeping your hairstyle in place for hours.

Disadvantages of Using Hair Putty

  • Learning Curve: Getting the right amount and application technique can take some practice, as using too much can make hair feel heavy.
  • Not for Sleek Styles: If you’re aiming for sleek, shiny hairstyles, hair putty may not be the best choice due to its matte finish.

Advantages of Using Pomade

  • Shine: Pomade is known for its ability to provide a glossy shine, ideal for polished, slicked-back looks.
  • Moisturizing: Many pomades contain oils that can help moisturize and condition the hair, making them a good option for dry hair types.
  • Hold Variety: Pomade comes in varying degrees of hold, from light to strong, allowing you to choose based on your styling needs.
  • Smooth Application: Thanks to its consistency, pomade spreads easily through hair, facilitating a smooth styling process.

Disadvantages of Using Pomade

  • Can be Greasy: Especially with oil-based pomades, there’s a risk of leaving hair looking greasy if used excessively.
  • Washability: Oil-based pomades can be challenging to wash out, requiring multiple shampoos to remove completely, which could lead to product buildup or strip natural oils from your hair.
  • Weight: Pomade can weigh down fine or thin hair, making it less ideal for those seeking volume or texture.

In the comparison of hair putty vs pomade, both products serve distinct styling needs and preferences. Hair putty offers a strong, flexible hold with a matte finish, ideal for textured, casual looks. On the other hand, pomade provides a sleek, shiny appearance, suitable for more polished styles. Considering these pros and cons can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your desired outcome and hair type.

Hair Putty vs Pomade: Suitability for Different Hair Types and Styles

Choosing between hair putty and pomade often comes down to your specific hair type and the style you're aiming for. Here's a guide to help you decide which product is best for your hair, whether it's fine, thick, curly, or straight.

Hair Putty for Different Hair Types

  • Fine Hair: Hair putty can add texture and volume to fine hair without weighing it down, making it appear fuller.
  • Thick Hair: Provides the control needed to manage and style thick hair, offering a strong hold that lasts.
  • Curly Hair: Helps define curls without sacrificing natural movement, giving a matte finish that reduces frizz.
  • Straight Hair: Ideal for adding texture and creating a more dynamic, tousled look that stays in place.

Pomade for Different Hair Types

  • Fine Hair: Use a lightweight, water-based pomade to avoid weighing hair down while adding a slight shine and maintaining style.
  • Thick Hair: Oil-based pomades can tame and sleeken thick hair, providing the necessary hold for structured styles.
  • Curly Hair: Adds definition and shine to curls, making them appear more polished and controlled.
  • Straight Hair: Excellent for creating sleek, smooth styles like classic pompadours or side parts that require a glossy finish.

Ideal Hairstyles Achieved with Hair Putty

  • Textured, casual looks: Perfect for achieving a bedhead look or a textured quiff that appears effortlessly styled.
  • Messy, tousled styles: Ideal for creating volume and movement, giving life to straight or fine hair.
  • Short to medium-length haircuts: Hair putty excels in styling shorter cuts, offering flexibility and hold without stiffness.

Ideal Hairstyles Achieved with Pomade

  • Slicked-back looks: Pomade is the go-to for a classic, sleek appearance, keeping hair perfectly in place with a shiny finish.
  • Pompadours and side parts: Provides the hold and shine needed for these polished, vintage-inspired hairstyles.
  • Curly and wavy hair styles: Enhances curls and waves with a touch of shine, reducing frizz and defining shape.

When considering hair putty vs pomade, think about the finish (matte vs. shiny) and the hold (flexible vs. strong) you prefer, as well as how each product interacts with your hair type. Whether you're aiming for a natural, textured look or a sleek, defined style, choosing the right product can elevate your hairstyle to the next level.

Hair Putty vs Pomade: Choosing the Right One for You

Deciding between hair putty vs pomade comes down to understanding your hair's needs and the style you wish to achieve. Each product offers unique benefits, but the right choice for you depends on several factors, including your hair type, preferred finish, and lifestyle. Here's how to make an informed decision in the hair putty vs pomade debate.

Consider Your Hair Type

  • Fine or Thin Hair: If volume is what you're after, hair putty is likely your best bet. Its lightweight formula can add texture without weighing your hair down.
  • Thick or Curly Hair: For controlling and defining thick or curly hair, pomade might be the way to go, especially if you're looking for a sleek finish.

Think About the Desired Finish

  • Matte Finish: Hair putty offers a natural, matte look that's perfect for casual, everyday styles.
  • Shiny Finish: If you prefer a glossy look that catches the light, pomade will provide the shine you're aiming for.

Reflect on Your Lifestyle

  • Active Lifestyle: If you're frequently on the move or involved in activities that might mess up your hair, consider hair putty for its reworkable qualities.
  • Professional or Polished Looks: For those needing a more refined style for work or special occasions, pomade can offer the sleek, controlled appearance you need.

Ease of Use and Maintenance

  • Washability: Water-based pomades are easier to wash out than oil-based ones, which is something to consider if you prefer not to shampoo daily. Hair putty typically washes out with less effort compared to oil-based pomade.
  • Application: Think about your morning routine. If you prefer a quick, fuss-free application, hair putty's flexibility might suit you. If you're willing to spend a bit more time for a polished look, pomade could be your go-to.

Experiment and Adjust

The best way to truly know which product suits you is to try them out. Start with small amounts to see how your hair reacts and adjust the quantity and type as needed. Your preference might even change based on the season, the current length of your hair, or simply your mood.

In the hair putty vs pomade discussion, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice enhances your natural hair type and aligns with your lifestyle and styling needs. Remember, the goal is to feel confident and comfortable with your hairstyle, so consider what matters most to you in a styling product.


Navigating the choice between hair putty vs pomade doesn't have to be a daunting task. By understanding the unique characteristics and benefits of each, you can make a decision that best suits your hair type, desired style, and lifestyle needs. Remember, hair putty offers a matte finish and flexible hold, making it ideal for natural, textured looks, while pomade provides a sleek, shiny finish for more polished styles.

Consider your daily routine, the amount of time you're willing to spend on your hair, and how important it is for your hairstyle to withstand your day-to-day activities. Whether you lean towards the versatility and natural finish of hair putty or the classic shine and strong hold of pomade, the right choice is the one that makes you feel confident and comfortable.

Don't be afraid to experiment with both products to truly understand their effects on your hair. Sometimes, the best way to decide is through trial and error, as your preferences may evolve over time. The debate between hair putty vs pomade ultimately comes down to personal choice and finding the product that aligns with your individual hair goals.

In conclusion, whether you choose hair putty or pomade, the goal is to enhance your natural style and feel your best. With the right product, application technique, and a little bit of creativity, you can achieve any look you desire. So, go ahead, make your choice, and embrace the endless possibilities of hair styling with confidence.

Older Post
Newer Post
Back to top

Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty

Shop now