Skip to content


Man using a tin of hair clay for men from Beard Beasts Mens Grooming - ideal for achieving natural, textured hairstyles. Learn more in the Clay vs Pomade guide.

Clay vs Pomade: The Ultimate Styling Product Guide for Your Hair

Are you torn between using hair clay or pomade? In the world of men's hairstyling, Clay vs Pomade is a common dilemma. Both products offer unique benefits, but which one is right for you? Whether you're looking for texture and volume or a sleek, polished finish, understanding the differences between hair clay and pomade can transform your styling game.

This guide will explore what makes each product unique, the benefits they offer, and how to choose the best one for your hair type and desired style. Ready to find your perfect styling match? Let's dive in!

What is Hair Clay?

Hair clay is a popular styling product known for its ability to add volume and texture while providing a natural, matte finish. Unlike gels and waxes, hair clay has a thicker consistency and is often infused with natural ingredients that not only style but also nourish the hair.

Tin of hair clay for men - the perfect product for achieving natural, textured hairstyles with a matte finish. Discover the benefits of hair clay in the Clay vs Pomade guide.

Key Ingredients in Hair Clays:

  • Bentonite Clay: Known for its ability to absorb oils and impurities, giving hair a clean, matte look.
  • Kaolin Clay: Offers a lighter hold and is gentler on the scalp, making it ideal for sensitive skin.
  • Beeswax: Adds a subtle hold and helps to lock in moisture.
  • Essential Oils: Often included for fragrance and their natural conditioning properties.

Benefits of Using Hair Clay

Volume and Texture

One of the standout benefits of hair clay is its ability to add volume and texture. The clay works by binding to each strand of hair, creating a fuller appearance without weighing it down. This makes it perfect for those with thinner hair looking to boost their hair's body.

Matte Finish

Unlike pomades, which often leave a shiny finish, hair clay provides a matte finish. This natural look is perfect for achieving effortless, everyday styles without appearing overly styled.

Natural Look

Because hair clay doesn't clump hair together, it maintains a natural look. Your hair will look styled yet touchable, making it great for casual and professional settings alike.

Types of Hair Clays

There are various types of hair clays, each with unique properties to suit different styling needs.

Type of Clay Properties
Bentonite Strong hold, excellent for oily hair, matte finish
Kaolin Light hold, suitable for sensitive skin, soft texture

Bentonite Clay is perfect for those seeking a strong hold and a completely matte finish. It's especially good for those with oily hair as it effectively absorbs excess oil.

Kaolin Clay offers a lighter hold and is ideal for people with sensitive skin. It gives a soft texture and is great for more natural, relaxed styles.

Best Hair Types for Clay

Ideal Hair Types and Lengths:

  • Short to Medium Length Hair: Hair clay is particularly effective for shorter styles, where adding texture and volume is desired.
  • Thin Hair: The volumizing properties of clay make it a great choice for those with thin or fine hair.
  • Oily Hair: As clay absorbs excess oil, it's perfect for those with oily scalps.

Suitable Hair Types:

  • Straight Hair: Works well to add texture and volume.
  • Wavy Hair: Enhances natural waves without adding shine.

By understanding what hair clay is and its various benefits, you can make an informed choice in the Clay vs Pomade debate. Hair clay offers a versatile, natural look that's perfect for a range of styles and hair types. Whether you're aiming for a casual day look or a more structured style, hair clay can be a reliable addition to your grooming routine.

What is Hair Pomade?

Hair pomade is a classic styling product known for its ability to provide a strong hold and a shiny finish. Unlike hair clay, pomade typically has a smoother, creamier consistency and is designed to give your hair a sleek, polished look. It’s ideal for styles that require precision and shine, like slick backs and pompadours.

Tin of hair pomade for men - ideal for achieving sleek, polished hairstyles with a shiny finish. Explore the benefits of hair pomade in the Clay vs Pomade guide

Main Ingredients in Pomades:

  • Petroleum Jelly: Common in oil-based pomades, offering a strong hold and high shine.
  • Beeswax: Adds structure and hold while providing some natural shine.
  • Lanolin: A moisturizing agent that helps keep hair supple.
  • Essential Oils and Fragrances: Enhance scent and provide conditioning benefits.
  • Water: Found in water-based pomades, making them easier to wash out and more flexible in hold.

Benefits of Using Hair Pomade

Shine and Hold

One of the primary benefits of pomade is its ability to provide shine and hold. Whether you choose an oil-based or water-based pomade, you can achieve a glossy finish that keeps your hair in place all day. This makes it perfect for formal styles and special occasions.

Versatility in Hairstyles

Hair pomade is incredibly versatile. You can use it to create a variety of styles, from classic slick backs to modern textured looks. Its ability to remain pliable means you can restyle your hair throughout the day without losing hold or shine.

Types of Hair Pomades

There are two main types of hair pomades: oil-based and water-based. Each has its own unique properties and benefits.

Type of Pomade Properties
Oil-based Strong hold, high shine, more difficult to wash out
Water-based Flexible hold, medium to high shine, easy to wash out

Oil-based Pomade offers a very strong hold and a high shine. It’s great for traditional styles that require a firm structure. However, it can be harder to wash out and may require multiple shampoos.

Water-based Pomade provides a more flexible hold and is much easier to rinse out with water. It still offers a good amount of shine but allows for restyling throughout the day without feeling greasy.

Best Hair Types for Pomade

Suitable Hair Types and Lengths:

  • Short to Medium Length Hair: Pomade works best on shorter styles that need definition and shine.
  • Thick Hair: The strong hold of pomade can help manage and style thicker hair types.
  • Curly Hair: Pomade can help define curls and reduce frizz, giving a polished look.

Ideal Hair Types:

  • Straight Hair: Perfect for achieving sleek, classic styles.
  • Wavy Hair: Enhances natural waves while providing control and shine.

By understanding the unique qualities and benefits of hair pomade, you can better decide whether it suits your styling needs in the Clay vs Pomade debate.

Pomade offers a sleek, polished finish perfect for a variety of classic and modern hairstyles, making it a versatile choice for many hair types and styles.

Whether you're preparing for a formal event or just want a refined everyday look, pomade can help you achieve the desired style with ease.

Comparing Hair Clay vs Pomade

When deciding between hair clay and pomade, it’s essential to consider various factors such as hold, finish, texture, volume, application, restyling, and ease of washing out. Here's a detailed comparison to help you make an informed choice in the Clay vs Pomade debate.

Hold and Finish

Product Hold Strength Finish
Hair Clay Medium to Strong Matte
Pomade Medium to Very Strong Shiny (oil-based) or Semi-Shiny (water-based)
  • Hair Clay provides a medium to strong hold, perfect for creating textured, natural looks with a matte finish. It's ideal for styles that require a firm yet pliable hold.
  • Pomade offers a range of hold strengths, from medium to very strong, depending on whether it’s oil-based or water-based. It typically gives a shiny finish, which is great for sleek, polished styles.

Texture and Volume

Aspect Hair Clay Pomade
Texture Adds significant texture Smoother, less textured
Volume Enhances volume, especially for fine hair Provides control but less volume
  • Hair Clay excels at adding texture and volume. It binds to each hair strand, creating a fuller appearance, making it perfect for those with thinner hair seeking more body and lift.
  • Pomade provides a smoother, more controlled look with less emphasis on texture. It’s excellent for achieving sleek styles but may not add as much volume as clay.

Application and Restyling

Aspect Hair Clay Pomade
Application Applied to dry or slightly damp hair Applied to damp or dry hair
Restyling Maintains shape, moderate restyling ability Easy to restyle, especially water-based pomades
  • Hair Clay is best applied to dry or slightly damp hair. It maintains its shape well but offers moderate restyling ability throughout the day.
  • Pomade can be applied to damp or dry hair. Water-based pomades, in particular, allow for easy restyling throughout the day, while oil-based pomades hold firmly but are less flexible.

Washing Out

Aspect Hair Clay Pomade
Ease of Washing Out Easy, usually one wash needed Water-based: easy, Oil-based: requires more effort
  • Hair Clay is generally easy to wash out with regular shampoo, often requiring just one wash.
  • Pomade varies in its washability:
    • Water-based Pomade: Easy to wash out with water and regular shampoo.
    • Oil-based Pomade: More challenging to remove, often needing multiple washes or a clarifying shampoo.

Summary: Clay vs Pomade

Here’s a quick overview to help you decide which product suits your needs:

Feature Hair Clay Pomade
Best For Textured, natural looks Sleek, polished styles
Hold Strength Medium to Strong Medium to Very Strong
Finish Matte Shiny (oil-based) or Semi-Shiny (water-based)
Texture High texture, adds volume Smooth, less textured
Ease of Application Dry or slightly damp hair Damp or dry hair
Restyling Ability Moderate High (water-based)
Washing Out Easy Easy (water-based), Challenging (oil-based)

Both hair clay and pomade have their unique advantages and ideal use cases. Hair clay is perfect for those seeking a textured, voluminous look with a matte finish. It’s easy to apply and wash out, making it convenient for everyday use. Pomade, on the other hand, is the go-to choice for sleek, classic styles that require strong hold and shine. While water-based pomades offer flexibility and ease of washing out, oil-based pomades provide unparalleled hold and luster.

In the Clay vs Pomade debate, the best choice ultimately depends on your hair type, desired style, and personal preferences. Experiment with both to find out which product works best for your unique hair styling needs.

How to Choose the Right Product for Your Hair

Choosing between hair clay and pomade can feel like a tough decision, but it doesn't have to be. By considering your hair type, desired hairstyle, lifestyle, and personal preferences, you can easily determine which product is best for you in the Clay vs Pomade debate.

Assessing Hair Type and Length

Hair Type:

  • Thin or Fine Hair: Opt for hair clay to add volume and texture without weighing your hair down.
  • Thick or Coarse Hair: Pomade is ideal for taming and controlling thick hair, providing a sleek finish.
  • Curly Hair: Pomade helps define curls and reduce frizz, giving a polished look.

Hair Length:

  • Short Hair: Both clay and pomade work well, but clay is great for adding texture, while pomade is perfect for sleek styles.
  • Medium Hair: Choose based on desired style – clay for a natural, textured look, pomade for controlled, shiny styles.
  • Long Hair: Pomade is often better for long hair to keep it smooth and manageable.
Hair Type Recommended Product Benefits
Thin/Fine Hair Clay Adds volume and texture
Thick/Coarse Pomade Controls and smooths hair
Curly Pomade Defines curls, reduces frizz
Short Hair Both Textured (Clay) / Sleek (Pomade)
Medium Hair Both Natural (Clay) / Polished (Pomade)
Long Hair Pomade Smooths and manages

Desired Hairstyle and Finish

Matching the Product to Your Style:

  • Textured, Natural Looks: Hair clay is your go-to. It provides a matte finish and adds body and volume.
  • Sleek, Polished Styles: Pomade is ideal. It offers a shiny finish and strong hold, perfect for formal styles like slick backs or pompadours.

Finish Preferences:

  • Matte Finish: Choose hair clay for a more understated, natural look.
  • Shiny Finish: Opt for pomade, especially oil-based, for a glossy, sleek appearance.

Lifestyle Considerations

Your daily routine and lifestyle can significantly impact your choice between clay and pomade.

Lifestyle Factors to Consider:

  • Active Lifestyle: If you’re often on the go or sweat frequently, hair clay’s matte finish and natural look can withstand activity better without becoming greasy.
  • Frequent Restyling: Water-based pomades are perfect if you like to restyle your hair throughout the day, as they are easy to reshape and manage.
  • Time for Hair Care: If you prefer a low-maintenance routine, hair clay is easier to wash out and generally requires less effort than oil-based pomade.
Lifestyle Factor Recommended Product Reason
Active Lifestyle Hair Clay Matte finish, natural look
Frequent Restyling Water-based Pomade Easy to reshape
Low Maintenance Hair Clay Easy to wash out

Personal Preference

Ultimately, your choice between hair clay and pomade should come down to personal preference. It’s essential to try both products to see which one feels and works best for your hair.

Experiment and Discover:

  • Trial and Error: Don’t be afraid to experiment with both clay and pomade to find out which one suits your hair type and desired style.
  • Product Combinations: Sometimes, a combination of both products can achieve the best results. For instance, use clay for texture and a light layer of pomade for shine and hold.
  • Seasonal Changes: Your hair needs might change with the seasons – clay might be better in summer for its matte finish, while pomade might work better in winter for added moisture and control.

In the Clay vs Pomade debate, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. By considering your hair type, desired hairstyle, lifestyle, and personal preferences, you can make an informed decision and achieve your perfect hair look. Remember, the key to great hair is finding the right product that suits your unique needs and style aspirations.

Popular Hair Clays and Pomades

Choosing the right product often comes down to finding the brands that work best for you. Here’s a look at some of the top hair clays and pomades to help you in your Clay vs Pomade decision.

Top Hair Clays

  1. Baxter of California Clay Pomade

    • Features: Firm hold, matte finish
    • Benefits: Ideal for creating textured looks with a natural feel. Contains natural ingredients like clay and beeswax for added hold and flexibility.
  2. Hanz de Fuko Claymation

    • Features: High hold, matte finish
    • Benefits: Offers incredible styling power while remaining easy to wash out. Perfect for achieving a messy, undone look with significant volume.
  3. Layrite Cement Clay

    • Features: Extreme hold, matte finish
    • Benefits: Provides all-day hold without weighing hair down. Ideal for short to medium hair lengths, offering a strong hold and natural appearance.
  4. American Crew Molding Clay

    • Features: Strong hold, medium shine
    • Benefits: Great for high-performance styling. Contains natural extracts like beeswax, providing pliability and strength.

Top Hair Pomades

  1. Suavecito Original Hold Pomade

    • Features: Medium hold, medium shine
    • Benefits: Water-based formula makes it easy to apply and wash out. Perfect for classic, sleek styles with moderate hold.
  2. Baxter of California Hard Cream Pomade

    • Features: Light hold, natural finish
    • Benefits: Provides a strong hold without the shine of traditional pomades. Ideal for those seeking a natural look with firm control.
  3. Layrite Superhold Pomade

    • Features: Strong hold, high shine
    • Benefits: Water-based, making it easy to rinse out. Excellent for managing thicker hair and achieving polished styles.
  4. Uppercut Deluxe Pomade

    • Features: Strong hold, high shine
    • Benefits: Versatile pomade suitable for a range of styles. Water-soluble, so it washes out easily and leaves no residue.

By exploring these popular hair clays and pomades, you can better understand which product might work best for your hair type and styling preferences. Remember, the key to great hair is finding the right product that suits your unique needs and style aspirations.

Tips for Using Hair Clay and Pomade

Using hair clay and pomade effectively can make a significant difference in your hairstyle. Here are some practical tips to help you get the best results from each product.

Application Techniques

Hair Clay:

  • Use a Small Amount: Start with a small pea-sized amount. You can always add more if needed.
  • Warm It Up: Rub the clay between your palms to warm it up. This makes it easier to spread through your hair.
  • Apply to Dry or Slightly Damp Hair: Hair clay works best on dry or slightly damp hair for maximum volume and texture.
  • Distribute Evenly: Use your fingers to distribute the clay evenly from root to tip, ensuring all sections are covered.

Hair Pomade:

  • Start Small: Begin with a dime-sized amount, especially if you’re using a strong-hold pomade.
  • Warm It Up: Like clay, rub the pomade between your hands to soften it.
  • Apply to Damp or Dry Hair: For a slick look, apply pomade to damp hair. For a more textured look, apply to dry hair.
  • Comb Through: Use a comb to distribute the pomade evenly, ensuring a smooth and polished finish.

Styling Tips

For Hair Clay:

  • Texture and Volume: Use your fingers to style and lift the hair, creating texture and volume.
  • Messy Look: For a casual, messy style, tousle your hair with your fingers after applying the clay.
  • Controlled Look: For a more controlled look, use a comb or brush to shape your hair after applying the clay.

For Hair Pomade:

  • Sleek Styles: Use a mens hair comb to create sleek styles like pompadours, slick backs, or side parts.
  • Layering: Apply pomade in layers if you need more hold or shine. Start with a small amount and build up as needed.
  • Restyling: For water-based pomades, a little water on your hands can help restyle your hair throughout the day.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Using Too Much Product:

  • Clay: Applying too much can make your hair feel heavy and greasy. Start small and add more if necessary.
  • Pomade: Overusing pomade, especially oil-based, can make your hair look greasy and weigh it down.

Incorrect Application:

  • Clay: Applying to wet hair can dilute the clay, reducing its effectiveness. Always apply to dry or slightly damp hair.
  • Pomade: Not warming up the pomade can make it difficult to spread evenly. Ensure you rub it between your hands first.

Not Washing Out Properly:

  • Clay: Even though clay is easy to wash out, make sure you use a good hair shampoo to remove all product residues.
  • Pomade: For oil-based pomades, use a clarifying shampoo to thoroughly clean your hair and avoid buildup.

Neglecting Hair Type and Style:

  • Clay: Not considering your hair type can lead to suboptimal results. Clay works best for adding texture and volume to thin or fine hair.
  • Pomade: Choosing the wrong type of pomade for your hair type or desired style can lead to disappointment. Ensure you select the right product based on your hair’s needs and your style goals.

By following these tips, you can make the most out of your hair clay and pomade, achieving the styles you desire while avoiding common pitfalls. Whether you prefer the textured, matte look of hair clay or the sleek, shiny finish of pomade, understanding the best application and styling techniques is key to mastering your hair game in the Clay vs Pomade debate.

FAQ: Common Questions About Hair Clay and Pomade

When it comes to choosing between hair clay and pomade, many questions arise. Here are some frequently asked questions to help you navigate the Clay vs Pomade decision.

Which is better, pomade or clay?

It depends on your desired hairstyle and hair type.

  • Hair Clay: Best for natural, textured looks with a matte finish. Ideal for adding volume and thickness.
  • Pomade: Perfect for sleek, polished styles with a shiny finish. Great for control and hold.
Hair Clay Pomade
Matte finish Shiny finish
Adds texture and volume Provides strong hold and control
Natural look Sleek, polished look
Ideal for fine to medium hair Suitable for all hair types

Is pomade stronger than clay?

Generally, pomade offers stronger hold than clay.

  • Pomade: Known for its strong hold and ability to keep hair in place all day. Available in both medium and strong hold variants.
  • Hair Clay: Offers a medium to strong hold but focuses more on texture and volume rather than a rigid hold.

Is pomade or clay better for fine hair?

Hair clay is typically better for fine hair.

  • Hair Clay: Adds volume and texture, making fine hair look thicker and fuller.
  • Pomade: Can weigh down fine hair if used excessively. Opt for lighter, water-based pomades if you prefer using pomade on fine hair.

Additional Common Questions

How do I wash out pomade and clay?

  • Hair Clay: Usually water-soluble, making it easy to wash out with regular shampoo.
  • Pomade: Water-based pomades wash out easily with shampoo, while oil-based pomades require a clarifying shampoo to remove all residues.

Can I use both clay and pomade together?

  • Yes, you can! Start with a small amount of clay to add volume and texture, then finish with a light layer of pomade for hold and shine.

How do I avoid greasy hair when using these products?

  • Use the right amount: Start with a small amount and add more if needed.
  • Choose the right product: Opt for water-based pomades if you have oily hair or prefer a lighter feel.
  • Proper washing: Ensure you wash out products thoroughly to prevent buildup.

What’s the best way to restyle my hair throughout the day?

  • Pomade: A little water or a wet comb can help restyle hair easily if using water-based pomade.
  • Hair Clay: Simply use your fingers to reshape and add volume as needed.

By understanding the key differences and benefits of hair clay and pomade, you can make an informed decision that suits your hair type and styling preferences. Whether you prefer the natural, voluminous look of clay or the sleek, controlled finish of pomade, there’s a product out there that will help you achieve your perfect hairstyle.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways from Clay vs Pomade

In the great debate of Clay and Pomade, your choice hinges on your hair type, desired style, and personal preferences. Here are the key takeaways from our guide:

Hair Clay

  • Definition: Provides a matte finish, texture, and volume.
  • Benefits: Ideal for natural looks, adding thickness, and controlling frizz.
  • Best for: Fine to medium hair, short to medium lengths.

Hair Pomade

  • Definition: Offers a shiny finish and strong hold.
  • Benefits: Perfect for sleek, polished styles with excellent control.
  • Best for: All hair types, particularly suitable for thicker hair.

Choosing between hair clay vs pomade depends on the look you want to achieve and how you want your hair to feel. Both products offer unique benefits, and experimenting with each can help you find the perfect fit for your style. Happy styling!

Older Post
Newer Post
Back to top

Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty

Shop now