Skip to content


A black and white photo showing a hand delicately scooping out pomade from an open container. The image suggests a comparison or choice between oil-based versus water-based pomade for styling.

Oil Based vs Water Based Pomade

In the quest for the perfect hairstyle, the choice between oil-based vs water-based pomade can be pivotal. Each type offers distinct benefits, from the lasting hold and glossy finish of oil-based pomades to the flexibility and easy washout of water-based alternatives.

This guide aims to unravel the differences, advantages, and considerations of both, helping you navigate your grooming journey with ease. Whether you're styling a classic pompadour or aiming for a more casual look, understanding these key aspects will ensure your hair not only looks great but remains healthy too.

Let's dive into the world of pomades to discover which type best suits your styling needs and lifestyle.

Understanding Pomades

Pomade, a long-standing favorite in men's grooming, has evolved from its original bear fat or lard formulations to include modern options like oil-based and water-based pomades. Each type offers distinct advantages: oil-based pomades deliver a lasting, slick shine, while water-based pomades provide a matte finish and easy washout. This diversity allows for versatile styling, from sleek, shiny looks to more subdued, natural appearances, making the choice between oil-based vs water-based pomade crucial for achieving your desired hair style.

Black and white image of an open tin of pomade on a textured surface with the lid placed beside it. This image hints at the theme of Oil Based vs Water Based Pomade for hair styling products.

The Rise of Pomade in Modern Styling

Pomades have made a big comeback in recent years, becoming a go-to for men who want to keep their hair looking sharp. With the resurgence of vintage hairstyles like pompadours and slick-backs, pomades have regained their popularity, evolving to meet modern needs. Today, the choice between oil-based vs water-based pomade is a common consideration for anyone looking to achieve the perfect hairstyle.

Oil-based pomades are praised for their strong hold and high shine, making them perfect for classic looks that last all day. However, they can be tough to wash out. On the other hand, water-based pomades offer a flexible hold and are easy to rinse out, making them a convenient option for men who prefer a more casual, easy-to-maintain style.

As the debate between oil-based vs water-based pomade continues, so do the varied preferences of users. Whether you seek a sleek, polished look or a relaxed style, there's a pomade for every hair type and preference. This diversity has solidified pomade's role in men's grooming, making it a key product for enhancing hairstyles, whether you lean towards the classic charm of oil-based or the convenience of water-based pomades.

Oil-based pomades are primarily made from natural oils such as petroleum, beeswax, and coconut oil. These ingredients give oil-based pomades their distinctive texture, which is thick and greasy to the touch. The shine and hold level of oil-based pomades are generally high, offering a slick, glossy look that lasts all day. This type of pomade is perfect for achieving classic hairstyles that require a stronghold and a noticeable sheen.

Pros of Oil-Based Pomade

  • Durability and Restyle Capability: One of the biggest advantages of oil-based pomades is their longevity. They don't dry out, allowing you to adjust your hairstyle throughout the day without needing to apply more product.
  • Superior Shine and Control for Thick Hair: If you're looking for a product that can tame thick, unruly hair and provide a polished look, oil-based pomades are the way to go. Their heavy-duty formula offers unmatched control and a lustrous finish.

Cons of Oil-Based Pomade

  • Difficulty in Washing Out: The same ingredients that give oil-based pomades their powerful hold also make them challenging to wash out. It often requires multiple shampoos to fully remove the product from your hair.
  • Potential for Scalp and Hair Issues: Because oil-based pomades are not easily washed out, they can build up on the scalp and hair over time. This buildup might lead to blocked pores and discomfort if not managed properly.

Ideal Styles and Occasions

Oil-based pomades are best suited for classic, slicked-back looks such as pompadours, side parts, and slick-backs. These styles benefit from the strong hold and high shine that oil-based pomades provide. Ideal for formal events or situations where you need your hairstyle to stay put for the entire day, oil-based pomades ensure that your hair looks as good in the evening as it did in the morning.

In deciding between oil-based vs water-based pomade for events like business meetings or weddings, oil-based is preferred for a classic, sophisticated look. Yet, for active lifestyles or those seeking simpler, natural styles, water-based pomades are the better choice, balancing ease and maintenance with styling needs.

Water-Based Pomade Explored

In the oil-based vs water-based pomade comparison, water-based pomades shine for their light formula and easy washability. Unlike the heavier oil-based options, these pomades blend water-soluble waxes and oils, offering a clean rinse. Their texture is smoother and less greasy, providing flexible to strong holds and varying from glossy to matte finishes. This versatility makes water-based pomades a popular choice in the oil-based vs water-based debate, appealing to those looking for both style and convenience.

Pros of Water-Based Pomade

  • Easy to Wash Out: The standout advantage of water-based pomades is their washability. Unlike oil-based pomades, they can be easily rinsed out with just water, making them a convenient choice for those who prefer a quick and simple grooming routine.
  • Less Buildup, Healthier for Hair and Scalp: Because they wash out so easily, water-based pomades reduce the risk of buildup, keeping the scalp and hair cleaner and healthier.

Cons of Water-Based Pomade

  • May Require Reapplication: Some water-based pomades may not hold up throughout the day as well as oil-based pomades, especially in humid conditions or if you're active, requiring you to reapply the product to maintain your style.
  • Different Varieties (Gel-Like vs. Traditional) and Their Effects: Water-based pomades come in various formulations, from gel-like to more traditional textures. Gel-like varieties can harden in the hair, offering a very strong hold but less flexibility, while traditional water-based pomades offer a balance between hold and pliability.

Ideal Styles and Occasions

Water-based pomades are versatile, making them suitable for a wide range of hairstyles from casual, textured looks to more polished styles. They're particularly well-suited for those who prefer a more natural look or need a product that can be easily adjusted or washed out at the end of the day.

Ideal for everyday use, water-based pomades can support styles like casual quiffs, textured crops, and other modern hairstyles that benefit from a product that isn't too heavy or shiny. They're also a great choice for anyone with an active lifestyle or those who prefer a grooming product that's easy to remove and won't cause buildup or scalp issues over time.

Whether you're heading to the office, out for a casual event, or simply going about your day-to-day activities, the debate between oil-based vs water-based pomade becomes relevant. Water-based pomades offer the flexibility and ease of use that can adapt to various lifestyles and styling needs, positioning themselves as a versatile choice in the oil-based vs water-based pomade discussion.

Oil-Based vs Water-Based Pomade: Head-to-Head Comparison

Choosing the right pomade can be crucial for achieving your desired hairstyle. In this guide, we'll dive into the key differences between oil-based vs water-based pomade, covering aspects like hold, shine, application, and their impacts on hair health and the environment.

Hold and Shine

Oil-Based Pomade: Known for its strong hold, oil-based pomades keep hair in place throughout the day, making them ideal for sleek, polished styles. They also offer a significant shine, giving hair a glossy, well-groomed appearance. However, this intense hold and shine may not be suitable for those seeking a more natural, flexible hairstyle.

Water-Based Pomade: Offers a range of holds from light to strong, depending on the formulation. While some water-based pomades can match the hold of oil-based products, they generally allow for more flexibility and natural movement in the hair. The shine varies too, with some providing a gloss similar to oil-based pomades, though many lean towards a more matte finish.

Application and Maintenance

Oil-Based Pomade: While providing excellent control and style, oil-based pomades can be a bit challenging to work with due to their thick consistency. They require more effort both in application and removal, often necessitating special shampoos or multiple washes to completely remove from the hair.

Water-Based Pomade: These are user-friendly, both in application and wash-out. They can be easily worked into the hair and adjusted throughout the day. When it's time to clean your hair, water-based pomades rinse out with minimal effort, making them a low-maintenance option.

Health and Environmental Considerations

Oil-Based Pomade: The ingredients in oil-based pomades can lead to buildup on the scalp and hair if not washed out properly, potentially causing scalp irritation or hair issues over time. Environmentally, the petroleum-based ingredients common in these products can raise concerns about sustainability and ecological impact.

Water-Based Pomade: Generally considered healthier for the scalp and hair, water-based pomades minimize the risk of irritation and buildup due to their washability. From an environmental perspective, many water-based pomades use more natural, less harmful ingredients, making them a more eco-friendly choice.

Choosing between oil-based vs water-based pomade depends on your styling needs, hair type, lifestyle, and environmental and health considerations. While oil-based pomades offer unparalleled hold and shine, they require more maintenance and may not be the best choice for scalp health.

Water-based pomades, on the other hand, provide flexibility, ease of use, and a healthier option for both the user and the environment. Consider your priorities and experiment to find the perfect pomade for your hair.

Oil Based vs Water Based Pomade: Making the Right Choice

When it comes to selecting the best pomade for your hair, there are several key factors to consider. Understanding these aspects can help you navigate the choice between oil-based vs water-based pomade more effectively, ensuring you pick a product that aligns with your grooming preferences and lifestyle.

Factors to Consider

  • Hair Type: The nature of your hair—whether it's thick, thin, curly, or straight—plays a significant role in choosing your pomade. Oil-based pomades often work best for thick and unruly hair, providing strong hold and shine. Water-based pomades, on the other hand, are suitable for all hair types, especially if you're looking for flexibility and an easier washout process.

  • Lifestyle: Your daily activities and routine should influence your decision. If you engage in sports or physical activities, a water-based pomade might be more practical due to its ease of washing. For those who prefer a set-and-forget style that lasts all day, an oil-based pomade could be the better option.

  • Preferred Hairstyles: Consider the hairstyles you favor. Oil-based pomades are ideal for classic, slick looks that require a glossy finish and strong hold. Water-based pomades offer a more natural appearance, perfect for casual or textured styles that you can easily restyle or wash out at the end of the day.

  • Health Considerations: Take into account any scalp or hair health issues. Oil-based pomades may lead to buildup and require more thorough washing, which could be a concern for sensitive scalps. Water-based pomades are generally lighter and less likely to cause buildup, making them a gentler choice.

Making an Informed Decision

By considering these factors, you can make a more informed choice between oil-based and water-based pomades. It's also worthwhile to experiment with both types to firsthand experience their effects on your hair and scalp. Remember, the best pomade for you is the one that meets your specific needs and helps you achieve your desired look with confidence and ease.

Frequently Asked Questions

Navigating the world of hair styling products, especially pomades, can raise many questions. Whether you're new to using pomade or considering a switch between oil-based and water-based formulas, you likely have some queries. Below, we address some of the most frequently asked questions about using pomade to help you achieve the perfect style with ease and confidence.

Can I switch between oil-based and water-based pomades?

Absolutely! Many men find that using both types for different occasions or styles works best. For instance, an oil-based pomade can be your go-to for formal events requiring a sleek look, while a water-based pomade is perfect for daily use or when you anticipate a more active day.

How can I remove oil-based pomade effectively?

To remove oil-based pomade, consider using a clarifying shampoo or a conditioner before shampooing. These products help break down the oils, making it easier to wash out the pomade. Some prefer to apply conditioner to dry hair, let it sit for a few minutes to break down the pomade, and then shampoo as usual.

Will using pomade cause hair loss?

No, using pomade does not directly cause hair loss. However, it's important to maintain a healthy scalp by regularly washing your hair to prevent buildup, which could potentially lead to hair thinning or scalp issues over time.

Can water-based pomade dry out my hair?

While water-based pomades are less likely to cause buildup, some formulas may contain alcohols or other ingredients that can dry out your hair with frequent use. Look for water-based pomades with hydrating ingredients if you have dry hair or are concerned about moisture.

Is pomade suitable for curly hair?

Yes, pomade can be great for curly hair. Water-based pomades are often preferred for curly hair as they provide hold without weighing down the curls or causing excessive buildup. However, oil-based pomades can also be used sparingly for added shine and control.

How much pomade should I use?

Start with a small amount, about the size of a pea, and work it through your hair. You can always add more if needed. The goal is to achieve your desired style without overloading your hair with product, which can make it look greasy or weigh it down.

By considering these FAQs, you can better understand how to choose and use oil-based vs water-based pomades to achieve your ideal hairstyle while keeping your hair and scalp healthy.

Concluding Oil Based vs Water Based Pomade

Choosing between oil-based vs water-based pomade boils down to your hair needs and styling preferences. Oil-based pomades offer a glossy, strong hold, perfect for enduring styles, while water-based pomades provide flexibility and easy washout, ideal for daily use. Each serves a unique purpose in a man's grooming routine, highlighting the importance of understanding both to find your perfect match.

Key Takeaways

  • Oil-Based Pomade: Perfect for achieving that timeless, slick look with maximum shine and hold. Best suited for those special occasions or when you need your hairstyle to withstand the test of time throughout the day. Ideal for individuals with thicker hair seeking control and luster.

  • Water-Based Pomade: Offers a versatile and healthier option for your hair and scalp, with the convenience of easy washing and less buildup. It's the go-to choice for daily wear, providing a more natural finish while still maintaining good hold. Great for all hair types and those seeking a balance between style and convenience.

Experimentation is key. Trying out both types can lead to surprising discoveries about what best complements your hair and lifestyle. Consider your hair type, the styles you aim to achieve, and how much maintenance you're willing to undertake. Our FAQs should have cleared up common queries, but the journey doesn't stop there.

In the end, the perfect pomade isn't just about the hold or shine it offers; it's about how it fits into your life and makes you feel. Whether you're drawn to the robust charm of oil-based pomades or the sleek practicality of water-based options, your choice should empower you to face the day with confidence and style. Your ideal pomade awaits—embrace the exploration and make your styling routine uniquely yours.

Older Post
Newer Post
Back to top

Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty

Shop now